Recherche avancée

Sur d’autres sites (7583)

• How Much H.264 In Each Encoder ?

  8 septembre 2010, par Multimedia Mike — General

  Thanks to my recent experiments with code coverage tools, I have a powerful new — admittedly somewhat specious — method of comparing programs. For example, I am certain that I have read on more than one occasion that Apple’s H.264 encoder sucks compared to x264 due, at least in part, to the Apple encoder’s alleged inability to exercise all of H.264′s features. I wonder how to test that claim ?

  Experiment
  Use code coverage tools to determine which H.264 encoder uses the most features.

  Assumptions

  • Movie trailers hosted by Apple will all be encoded with the same settings using Apple’s encoder.
  • Similarly, Yahoo’s movie trailers will be encoded with consistent settings using an unknown encoder.
  • Encoding a video using FFmpeg’s libx264-slow setting will necessarily throw a bunch of H.264′s features into the mix (I really don’t think this assumption holds much water, but I also don’t know what “standard” x264 settings are).

  Methodology

  • Grab a random Apple-hosted 1080p movie trailer and random Yahoo-hosted 1080p movie trailer from Dave’s Trailer Page.
  • Use libx264/FFmpeg with the ‘slow’ preset to encode Big Buck Bunny 1080p from raw PNG files.
  • Build FFmpeg with code coverage enabled.
  • Decode each file to raw YUV, ignore audio decoding, generate code coverage statistics using gcovr, reset stats after each run by deleting *.gcda files.

  Results

  • x264 1080p video : 9968 / 134203 lines
  • Apple 1080p trailer : 9968 / 134203 lines
  • Yahoo 1080p trailer : 9914 / 134203 lines

  I also ran this old x264-encoded file (ImperishableNightStage6Low.mp4) through the same test. It demonstrated the most code coverage with 10671 / 134203 lines.

  Conclusions
  Conclusions ? Ha ! Go ahead and jump all over this test. I’m already fairly confident that it’s impossible (or maybe just very difficult) to build a single H.264-encoded video that exercises every feature that FFmpeg’s decoder supports. For example, is it possible for a file to use both CABAC and CAVLC entropy methods ? If it’s possible, does any current encoder do that ?

• Monster Battery Power Revisited

  28 mai 2010, par Multimedia Mike — Python, Science Projects

  So I have this new fat netbook battery and I performed an experiment to determine how long it really lasts. In my last post on the matter, it was suggested that I should rely on the information that gnome-power-manager is giving me. However, I have rarely seen GPM report more than about 2 hours of charge ; even on a full battery, it only reports 3h25m when I profiled it as lasting over 5 hours in my typical use. So I started digging to understand how GPM gets its numbers and determine if, perhaps, it’s not getting accurate data from the system.

  I started poking around /proc for the data I wanted. You can learn a lot in /proc as long as you know the right question to ask. I had to remember what the power subsystem is called — ACPI — and this led me to /proc/acpi/battery/BAT0/state which has data such as :

  present :                 yes
  capacity state :          ok
  charging state :          charged
  present rate :            unknown
  remaining capacity :      100 mAh
  present voltage :         8326 mV
  

  "Remaining capacity" rated in mAh is a little odd ; I would later determine that this should actually be expressed as a percentage (i.e., 100% charge at the time of this reading). Examining the GPM source code, it seems to determine as a function of the current CPU load (queried via /proc/stat) and the battery state queried via a facility called devicekit. I couldn’t immediately find any source code to the latter but I was able to install a utility called ’devkit-power’. Mostly, it appears to rehash data already found in the above /proc file.

  Curiously, the file /proc/acpi/battery/BAT0/info, which displays essential information about the battery, reports the design capacity of my battery as only 4400 mAh which is true for the original battery ; the new monster battery is supposed to be 10400 mAh. I can imagine that all of these data points could be conspiring to under-report my remaining battery life.

  Science project : Repeat the previous power-related science project but also parse and track the remaining capacity and present voltage fields from the battery state proc file.

  Let’s skip straight to the results (which are consistent with my last set of results in terms of longevity) :

  
  
  

  So there is definitely something strange going on with the reporting— the 4400 mAh battery reports discharge at a linear rate while the 10400 mAh battery reports precipitous dropoff after 60%.

  Another curious item is that my script broke at first when there was 20% power remaining which, as you can imagine, is a really annoying time to discover such a bug. At that point, the "time to empty" reported by devkit-power jumped from 0 seconds to 20 hours (the first state change observed for that field).

  Here’s my script, this time elevated from Bash script to Python. It requires xdotool and devkit-power to be installed (both should be available in the package manager for a distro).
  

  PLAIN TEXT

  PYTHON :

  1. # !/usr/bin/python
  2.  
  3. import commands
  4. import random
  5. import sys
  6. import time
  7.  
  8. XDOTOOL = "/usr/bin/xdotool"
  9. BATTERY_STATE = "/proc/acpi/battery/BAT0/state"
  10. DEVKIT_POWER = "/usr/bin/devkit-power -i /org/freedesktop/DeviceKit/Power/devices/battery_BAT0"
  11.  
  12. print "count, unixtime, proc_remaining_capacity, proc_present_voltage, devkit_percentage, devkit_voltage"
  13.  
  14. count = 0
  15. while 1 :
  16.   commands.getstatusoutput("%s mousemove %d %d" % (XDOTOOL, random.randrange(0,800), random.randrange(0, 480)))
  17.   battery_state = open(BATTERY_STATE).read().splitlines()
  18.   for line in battery_state :
  19.     if line.startswith("remaining capacity :") :
  20.       proc_remaining_capacity = int(line.lstrip("remaining capacity : ").rstrip("mAh"))
  21.     elif line.startswith("present voltage :") :
  22.       proc_present_voltage = int(line.lstrip("present voltage : ").rstrip("mV"))
  23.   devkit_state = commands.getoutput(DEVKIT_POWER).splitlines()
  24.   for line in devkit_state :
  25.     line = line.strip()
  26.     if line.startswith("percentage :") :
  27.       devkit_percentage = int(line.lstrip("percentage :").rstrip(’\%’))
  28.     elif line.startswith("voltage :") :
  29.       devkit_voltage = float(line.lstrip("voltage :").rstrip(’V’)) * 1000
  30.   print "%d, %d, %d, %d, %d, %d" % (count, time.time(), proc_remaining_capacity, proc_present_voltage, devkit_percentage, devkit_voltage)
  31.   sys.stdout.flush()
  32.   time.sleep(60)
  33.   count += 1